top of page

Reprimand housing minister over Greenbelt land swap: Ontario integrity watchdog

The Ontario Integrity Commissioner's report has called for the reprimand of Housing Minister Steve Clark following his involvement in a controversial Greenbelt land swap process. The report, authored by J. David Wake, cites Clark's inadequate oversight and flawed decision-making in the rushed development of ecologically sensitive Greenbelt lands for housing purposes.

Premier Doug Ford's office has indicated that Minister Clark will retain his position, although potential sanctions were not mentioned. The report highlights how private developers' interests appeared to influence the process, revealing a lack of transparency and ethical breaches in the Greenbelt development project.

The Greenbelt, established in 2005 to protect ecologically significant lands, faced the removal of 2,995 hectares for housing developments. The report also brings to light the connections between developers and government officials, raising concerns about undue influence on decisions related to the Greenbelt.

The investigation delved into the role of Clark's chief of staff, Ryan Amato, who played a central role in the development process. Amato's actions were found to be deceptive and manipulative, implying Premier Ford's involvement and influencing land selection criteria. This chaotic and non-transparent process favored certain developers and raised suspicions among others.

The report's findings have sparked calls for Minister Clark's resignation from opposition parties. However, Premier Ford's office has expressed support for Clark, emphasizing their commitment to housing goals and process improvement. The report has also fueled demands to reverse the Greenbelt land removals in a bid to restore the reputation of the program.

The controversy surrounding the Greenbelt land swap raises questions about lobbying rules and ethics within the Ontario government. The report highlights instances of unregistered lobbyists and the acceptance of gifts for access to policy discussions. It calls for stronger lobbying regulations and more effective penalties to ensure transparency and accountability in decision-making processes.

The Greenbelt land swap was proposed as a solution to housing affordability issues, yet experts have criticized its inefficiency in addressing the larger housing crisis. First Nations leaders have also voiced concerns, demanding Minister Clark's resignation or removal due to mishandling of the Greenbelt land changes.

In conclusion, the Integrity Commissioner's report sheds light on a flawed Greenbelt land swap process and the involvement of Housing Minister Steve Clark. The recommendation for reprimand underscores the need for ethical and transparent decision-making in matters that impact sensitive ecosystems and public interest. The report's implications extend beyond individual accountability, emphasizing the importance of robust governance and public participation in shaping environmental policies.